What’s the Difference Between Guarantees and Indemnities?

It is very important that anyone who is asked to provide a guarantee or indemnity understands precisely what their liabilities are under the arrangements.

In this article, we identify the distinguishing features of both guarantees and indemnities and consider the significant differences between the two kinds of arrangements.

 

Features of a guarantee

The most common example of a contract of guarantee is where one person (guarantor) agrees to be responsible to a bank (creditor) for the debts of a friend, relative, business colleague, or related company (debtor), who is borrowing money from the bank.

A guarantee contract includes three parties, namely the –

  • creditor who is granting the loan;
  • debtor who is using the amount of loan; and
  • guarantor who is giving the guarantee.

The liability of a guarantor is a secondary obligation which is only enforceable if the debtor fails to perform the obligations which have been guaranteed. If the primary obligation of the debtor is discharged or becomes void, the guarantee falls away.

Features of an indemnity

An indemnity is similar to an insurance contract. It is a way of allocating and managing risk.

An indemnity is often described as a contract by one party to keep the other harmless against loss. Essentially, the person providing the indemnity says, “If X happens, I will pay for any loss or damages you suffer as a result.”

Indemnities can come in many different forms and will depend largely on how the parties to the contract have agreed to allocate risk. Some examples include:

  • Bare indemnity: “A” indemnifies “B” against a loss or liability incurred in connection with specified circumstances, without setting any specific limitations.
  • Proportionate indemnity: “A” indemnifies “B” against losses except those incurred as a result of any act or omission of “B”.
  • Third party indemnity: “A” indemnifies “B” against liabilities to or claims of “C”.
  • Party/Party indemnity: each party to a contract indemnifies the other for loss occasioned as a result of the indemnifier’s breach of contract.
  • Reverse/reflexive indemnity: “A” indemnifies “B” against loss or liability incurred as a result of party “B”’s own acts or omissions.
  • Compensatory and “prevent loss” indemnities: A compensatory indemnity is expressed as an obligation to pay or compensate for loss suffered. A prevent loss indemnity is a “hold harmless” indemnity.

A contract of indemnity is a primary liability and may arise from an express or implied contract, or in equity.,

Differences between guarantees and indemnities

The key differences between guarantees and indemnities include:

  • a guarantee is a secondary liability, which means that there will be another person who is primarily liable for the obligation; whereas, an indemnity imposes a primary liability.
  • in most States, guarantees must be in writing or evidenced in writing, whereas indemnities do not have to be in writing and may be implied by the Courts.
  • a guarantor’s liability is limited by the extent of the debtor’s liability. In contrast, an indemnifier’s liability is determined by the terms of the indemnity.
  • a guarantor is discharged from liability if the principal contract is void or unenforceable, whereas an indemnifier generally remains liable if another associated transaction is unenforceable or void.
Function of guarantees and indemnities

A guarantee is usually used to provide protection to a person, typically a bank or finance company, against loss suffered through entering into a transaction if the obligations of the other party to that transaction are not performed. It reduces the credit risk faced by a bank by giving the bank an entitlement to demand payment from the guarantor in the event of the debtor’s default.

In contrast, indemnities are designed to allocate risk between various parties to a contract, to eliminate the need to show causation as an element of a claim, and to avoid the need to mitigate loss.

Indemnity clauses can be found in many different types of commercial contracts, for example, leases, sale of goods, construction contracts, manufacturing contracts and service agreements.

Conclusion 

Both guarantees and indemnities can impose complex and, in some cases, harsh obligations. As such, they should not be agreed to lightly and should only be considered after obtaining legal advice as to the effect of the specific terms created by the arrangements.

If you or someone you know wants more information or needs help or advice, please contact us on (08) 9380 9288 or email guy@dclawyers.com.au, robert@dclawyers.com.au or jonathan@dclawyers.com.au.